Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Curtis Chase's avatar

On Andrew Sullivan’s substack, he has a nice interview with Francis Collins about trying to square faith with a belief in science and our species’ hideous history. Collins notes that “there is evidence, but not proof” in a Great Deity, which may be the best framing we can get. All around me are miracles - the music of Coltrane and Clapton, the science that is saving my wife’s life, the crazy and non-sensical, yet thriving, City of New York. Those who decide they have all the answers seem doomed to commit untold acts of evil and appear doomed to a life of disappointment.

As for the Roman Emperor of our own time, does not the Mad King remind you more than anyone else (ironically given his fixations) of Commodus? If he is killed in the bathtub by his Praetorian guard, that will indeed be proof of God’s existence. And, yes, then as now, we could use a Senate that finds its voice and dignity.

Expand full comment
Stuart Kenney's avatar

Thank you for this erudite history of Judaism and Christianity. I appreciate your recognition of the aesthetic of the Catholic mass in both the Roman and, more so, the Eastern Orthodox church. Frankly, it is what kept me from leaving the Church because of the evil of sexual abuse. The Church needs drastic reform. Women should be priests, and priests should be able to marry. That's how it was at the dawn of Christianity. The misogynistic departure from those historic norms is traditional, not doctrinal, and therefore is subject to change.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts